Monday, July 31, 2006

Palestine, Israel and Lebanon


People of the Middle East (All photos: Norwegianblogger)

I haven’t really written much about the situation in the Middle East in this blog. It’s incredibly difficult to be objective and there are many load voices wanting us to share their views. In spite of this I don’t think we should be silent. We are all responsible as part of the human race to care, to use our thoughts and hearts to contribute and to say it out load and clear that we are all brethren: Israelis, Palestinians, the Lebanese and the rest of us. There’s so much suffering and pain in the region and the question is: Are we entitled to speak about this conflict when we’re living far away, not being personally involved? Am I entitled?

At times I’ve spoken to people from the region and I’ve heard that as a Norwegian I can’t understand the situation, and I guess there’s truth in this, but that’s when we look at ourselves as Israelis, Palestinians or Norwegians. We shouldn’t forget that we’re all first and foremost human beings, in need of others, craving for understanding, love and someone who cares, and frightened to death by war, pain and loss. Most of us have experienced loss, the emptiness and rage we feel when a loved one has lost his life, in accidents, in sickness or in war. At a personal level we’re living in a situation where death is as evident in our lives as life. It’s a part of being human.

How are we to understand and how are we to be able to lift our voices in a situation as the one in the Middle East? It takes time and I guess we have to listen for what we have in common; our humanness. Are we able to forget the dividing lines and listen to the joys, the pain and the fright in the voices of the people in the region? I’m not saying that we are not to criticize or argue about politics, but I think we have to start with acknowledging our common humanness.

A few years ago I was in Southern France, in a little idyllic town called Menton. From the hostel there’s a view of the Mediterranean and the beautiful coastline of the Cote D’Azur. A very peaceful setting and the porch is a wonderful place for conversations with people from different parts of the world. One evening I met an Israeli couple in their early twenties. This was during a very turbulent time in Israel with a lot of suicide bombings, and they said that it was incredibly difficult to get it off their minds. Even in peaceful Menton they were not able to let it go. At the beach they’d seen some luggage and thought immediately that it was a bomb. They had to convince themselves that they were in France and that nothing would harm them there. Every time they went out to a café, a disco or to meet their friends in a public area in Israel they went out with the knowledge that they could be killed. From a very early age this was a part of their daily lives, and after twenty years with this kind of fear, it was a part of their mindset.

How are we to comprehend this? Do we have these kinds of experiences as Norwegians? Probably not, but it’s very close to what could be called a phobia. Some of us are scared of heights, of open places, of masses of people, of birds or of insects – it’s a part of our mindset. Sometimes it really makes life difficult. Living with fear is not easy, but probably also a part of being human. Being scared could either make us distance us from others or draw us closer to each other. To acknowledge your own fears and to share your thoughts about them could help us understand and recognize our common humanness. By listening to this Israeli couple I was connected to them, because I could relate to my fears and was able to get an impression of how it is to live in conflict. The difference between a phobia and the situation in Israel is that in this situation the fear is justified. This couple had lost friends and family, and knew that next time it could be them. As a fellow human being we should be outraged of the fact that someone has to live with fears like this!
Later I’ve listened to Palestinians who are forced to stand in lines for hours just to be able to visit relatives or get to work, being abused, yelled at and treated like second-rate citizens, treated differently because of their ethnicity and background. A sad, sad situation! Are we able to relate? Have we been abused, yelled at or treated differently because of ethnicity, gender, orientation or age? Yeah, unfortunately it’s a part of being human, but who are we to make walls, to separate people because of their ethnicity, to abuse, to look down at, to treat differently? We should be outraged!

Lebanon – a country caught between the actions of their neighbors, a more or less innocent bystander to groups and countries making this beautiful country into a battleground. Losing inhabitants in massacres and attacks that should make the world outraged!

Well, the peoples of the Middle East are outraged, and they have every right to be filled with rage, but where does it leave us as human beings? Our rage could separate us or draw us closer. Do we see each other as human beings or as representatives of nations or groups or as the enemy? Politics is not about actions between politicians, it’s about fighting for the right of the Israeli couple to live without fear of being killed when they dance to celebrate life, it’s about the Palestinians right to lift their heads and walk freely to their neighbors, to be met by a smile instead of a gun, it’s about the Lebanese people’s right to live peacefully, but when it all comes down it’s about our rights as human beings to live in peace, to love, to talk freely, to share life with all, and to see our neighbors as brothers and sisters, here to make this earth our common HOME. Please politicians, please Palestinians, please Israelis, please Norwegians and Africans, Americans, Asians, Europeans, Australians; make this world a home for all of us!
People of the Middle East & me (All photos: Norwegianblogger)

6 comments:

Geir Skårland said...

I think you can be blinded just as much by being close to a situation as by being far away.

I am also very upset about what's going on. And it's exactly what you're writing about, "crimes against humanity" is a strong concept which shouldn't be abused, but everytime a human being is innocently wounded, a great or smaller crime against humanity is committed. And it's painful to watch.

And I can't help thinking that the Israeli campaign against the Hizbollah costs to much in terms of civilian casualties. I sincerely hope they would have gained more international support, perhaps even from arabs, by taking some more damage rather than dealing so much out. There's a limit to how much one should take before action is initiated, but as a relatively new state in the region, I hoped they would be careful rather than beliggerent.

Norwegianthinker said...

Yeah, true, but at the same time: I listened to CNN tonight hearing the Iranian president say (http://www.cnn.com/2006/WORLD/meast/08/03/iran.israel.ap/index.html)that destroying Israel would solve the problems in the Middle East. There's a lot to be said about Israel's government, but faced with these kind of threats I guess the options are more limited. It's not an excuse for Israeli government's behavior (especially not towards the Palestinians), but in a situation of fear attack is often the easiest solution. Unfortunately!

Anonymous said...

Freedom always comes at a cost: freedom from fear, discrimination, freedom of religion, all freedom. In the same way, rights are only given to those who earn them by being responsible. When a person commits murder their right to walk the streets is taken away because they have proven that they are not responsible citizens. Similarly, the person who aids a murderer is also being irresponsible and therefore forfeit their rights. Lebanon has been aiding and abetting terrorists/murderers for years. By housing murderers, they must recognize that they are in danger as well. It is unfortunate that civilians are being injured, but I would argue that if fingers are being pointed, they should be at the Lebanese government for puting their people in this dangerous situation.

Helge Årsvoll said...

Well, this is something really complicated. I really do not know how to think about the situation down in the middle east.

But i think you have a sensible approach to this. Thinking of what is needed if we all are going to live on this earth.

Dialogue and trying to understand has been and still is the most important factors in the project of making peace in this world.

I agree with United Nations special co-ordinator (for middle east peace process), Terje Roed-Larsen in what he said some days ago in an interview with NRK (The official Norwegian, national TV-Channel). He said that even if it seems to be totally impossible, we (United Nations) will fight for the dialouge between the parts in this conflict.

And Per, Menton is a very peaceful place. I can just imagine how a contrast it was to meet the fear there... your friends from Israel.

Norwegianthinker said...

First of all, to "Your friend" thanks for sharing your view on the situation. You are probably right, the government of Lebanon has a role in this, but that does not take away the pain of the civilians caught in the crossfire. Better than pointing fingers, I hope that we are able to ask: Where do we go from here? We have to start with acknowledging every single person in the Middle East (Muslims, Jews, Christians and all the others) as sisters and brothers caught in a spiral of hate, revenge and pain, but not beyond the ability to find it in their hearts to forgive, redeem and build a new future for the region, as Helge says: Dialogue and understanding are the major factors!

troro - the artists behind said...

Last post in this blog was in 2006, but I couldn't pass without leaving a message.
I feel proud to read the article and the comments and I think understanding the middle east is quite a big thing that takes a long long time. Meanwhile, we cannot just wait til the procedure of understanding is completely completed, we got to do something to show our humanity... no matter which side we are...
and here we start a little project in Lebanon: an aid project to help people help themselves. It is an art and humanitarian project:
www.beitelfounoun.blogspot.com